What is the best name for me (my name is Madison in real life)

The names that quickly come to mind for me, for some reason: Cory, Claire, Trista(n), Nicoletta, Tia, Tabitha, Talia, Stacia, Thea, Tira, Calista, Krista, and lots if others. :)

Of yours, I voted for Abigail. :) I agree you're not really a Madison. You're too unique-seeming for that name. You're definitely not a Maddy! You're a good example of why I wish parents would spend time with their babies before naming them. You seem to have a pretty distinct character about you.